Skip to content

Be sure to lay out the welcome mat

By Rich Kaminski, research director at WSL Strategic Retail

Photo by Tom Official / Unsplash

It’s an old trope, but it has a kernel of truth. You walk into a store and immediately feel like you’re not welcome. Maybe the employees get a little bit quieter. Maybe they’re staring at you. Maybe you’re not sure what it is, but something has changed and you no longer are sure if you’re really meant to be there. And whether you wanted to buy something or not — whether you could afford something or not — you’re now confronted with that judgment call. And then you have to make a decision yourself — do you leave, removing yourself from the situation or do you not give them the satisfaction and linger there, maybe proving that you belong and even deserve to shop there?

This experience is back in people’s minds for an admittedly somewhat whimsical reason, as pop singer Kelly Clarkson has become embroiled in an online feud with a boutique Brooklyn toy and knick-knack retailer over artisanal bird figurines. To make a long story short, there seems to be a miscommunication over the cost of two different, handmade, very expensive bird sculptures with varying (but still high!) price points and very different availability. And like many things, this misunderstanding has transferred to social media, where fans of the singer and supporters of the store are clashing, particularly as Clarkson felt as though she was being seen as “undeserving” of the more expensive item, and perhaps of even being in the store itself.

Aside from the (hopefully) low stakes entertainment of this experience, this is a neat, little case study of the importance of the in-store experience for shoppers, particularly when it comes to high-ticket items. A recent EY survey of more than 1,600 consumers across 11 markets who make at least $100,000 a year, found that over two-thirds of these shoppers who shop at brand-owned luxury stores are extremely satisfied with their experience. This is well above the around half who are extremely satisfied by the shopping experience on brand websites. And it aligns with what we’re seeing in our own forthcoming research on how U.S. shoppers think about value. In our survey, 72% of shoppers making over $100,000 agree with the statement, “Excellent customer service and knowledgeable employees increase a company’s value.”

The in-store experience really cannot be beat when moving into that luxury space. These shoppers appreciate the “pampering” that defines the in-store interactions. They like feeling welcomed, attended to, and guided and reassured by knowledgeable insiders who make them feel confident in their purchases. In a recent episode of our Future Shop podcast with Ron Johnson, he detailed how these same principles of belonging and guidance were integral to the creation of the Apple Store that we all know today. We see the “luxury experience” can be broadened to incorporate many shopping experiences where high costs are at stake or niche knowledge is needed to reassure shoppers.

We know that this experience is hard to replicate online and can be an effective differentiator in a brick-and-mortar experience. But the Kelly Clarkson feud illustrates that the in-person stakes are high as well. It’s not enough to just have an appealing and exciting storefront with knowledgeable insiders. There are two sides to the story, but this experience hammers home the necessity in making sure that the in-store experience is clearly mapped out and designed to make everyone feel welcome.

 Rich Kaminski is the research director at WSL Strategic Retail.

Latest

A new leader for a new time

A new leader for a new time

The top priority for Wysong, who for the past 16 years has been CEO of CARE Pharmacies, is to accelerate the transformation, which is already well under way. 

Handing AI the map, ‘Not the Wheel’

Handing AI the map, ‘Not the Wheel’

Sally Lyons Wyatt, Circana’s global consumer goods and food service chief advisor, summed it up: “Consumers are ready for a copilot that simplifies decisions, not an autopilot that removes them.”